R.I.P. Sinead

I had been planning on bringing back my occasional series Listen To The Band for this week’s midweek post. I had decided on the band and chosen the songs, but hadn’t started writing. But that plan went out of the window when the sad news filtered through last night of the passing of Sinead O’Connor at the age of just 56. I have hardly ever played her songs here: just the one, in fact, that gets a repeat airing at Christmas, so I felt it the least I could do to redress the balance – belatedly, I know – by playing a few in her memory.

Much has been said and written about Sinead over the years, about her troubled upbringing and her own issues. And there was the time when she ripped up a photo of Pope John Paul II on Saturday Night Live in 1992, in protest at the Catholic Church’s failure to take action against paedophile priests. Nine years later she was proved to have been right, when John Paul II acknowledged the problem, but the damage to her career had been done. Those are things for another day, though – today I want to share some of her music and her beautiful voice.

Though this was actually her third single, this is the song that first brought her to our attention:

Mandinka was released as a single on 1 December 1987, a couple of days after the release of her debut album, The Lion And The Cobra, on which it also featured. She was just 21 at the time, and we recognised that a new star was in the making. The single peaked at #6 in her native Ireland, at #17 in the UK, and at #14 on the US Dance Club chart. The album got to #3 in Ireland, #27 in the UK and #36 in the US.

It was Sinead’s second album that turned her into a major star, and one song from it in particular. This is one of the most famous music videos of all time, and I still find it bringing a tear to my eye even now, more than thirty years later:

She has more than 1m subscribers on YouTube, and that video has had more than 404m views. I suspect it will be getting a few more in the coming days. Nothing Compares 2 U is, as I’m sure you know, a song written and originally performed by Prince, but Sinead made it her own. It was released as a single in January 1990, a couple of months ahead of the album on which it is included, I Do Not Want What I Haven’t Got. Both the single and the album were massive hits, topping the charts in Ireland, the UK, the US, and in countless other countries as well. The single has sold more than 3.5m copies, and the album more than 7m. In case you didn’t know, the tears are genuine: Sinead has said that she was thinking of her mother, who had died in a car accident in 1985, and with whom she had shared a troubled relationship.

Her next album, Am I Not Your Girl? came out in September 1992. It was nowhere near as successful, but still achieved respectable chart placings: #8 in Ireland, #6 in the UK and #27 in the US, and it included her first cover of an Andrew Lloyd Webber song. This is one you will also know, but have you heard it sung as delicately as this:

Don’t Cry For Me Argentina is, of course, from the musical Evita. There have been many other recordings but I think this is by far and away the best. It was released as a single, but only made #53 here, and didn’t chart in Ireland or the US. The original version by Julie Covington, who played the role in the first stage production, is very good and was a UK #1, and even Madonna’s dirge made #3 here. Sometimes there can be no justice, it seems.

I mentioned at the beginning that before today I had only played one of Sinead’s songs. I know it is out of season for it, but as it is so lovely I’m including it again today:

Silent Night was released as a non-album single at Christmas 1991, and made #12 in Ireland and #60 in the UK. I think the song and the video are lovely, and deserved better.

Just one more song to play you. This is one of the tracks from Sinead’s blockbuster album, and it seems right to play it, given its title, The Last Day Of Our Acquaintance:

Although that’s the final song for today I thought I’d share one further video. I found this interview on the BBC’s Breakfast show from 2014 which gives a nice reminder of what Sinead was like: honest, intelligent, witty. It is a fitting way to end this tribute:

R.I.P. Sinead. I hope you find the peace that has eluded you. Thank you for the music, and for being you. Nothing Compares 2 U. 💐

65 thoughts on “R.I.P. Sinead

  1. Pingback: Goodbye July | Take It Easy

  2. A beautiful tribute to Sinead, Clive she had such a beautiful haunting voice and I love her version of Silent Night and play it most xmases on my blog it seems that after all she should have been applauded and not vilified for tearing up a picture of the Pope as the Catholic church has an awful record for abusing children in their care xx

    Liked by 1 person

  3. Pingback: Lisa Marie’s Week In Review: 7/24/23 — 7/30/23 | Through the Shattered Lens

  4. Clive, well done. Thanks for sharing her version of “Don’t cry for me Argentina.” It is outstanding.

    With the higher preponderance of pedophile priests in Ireland than elsewhere, that alone defends her tearing up the picture of the pope who tolerated a culture of cover-up. If you ever want to get really ticked off, watch the documentary “Mea Maxima Culpa” about the decades long cover up of pedophile priests at a boys school for the deaf in Wisconsin. At the end of the documentary, we learned there was a similar school of abused boys with two hours of the Vatican.

    Further, a documentary of O’Connor’s own life, reveals her mother was so troubled as a Catholic girl where thoughts of boys were a sin and if you kissed or hugged a boy you were punished, her mother carried the lack of esteem for the rest of her life. This was an additional reason for her tearing up the picture of the pope.

    Her bravery should be applauded. And, yet she was vilified. Who is the greater threat, the bishops that covered up and paid off the victims of 95 or so priests in the Boston area as reported in the movie on the Boston Herald called “Spotlight” or Sinead O’Connor? What about the sexually abusive priests?

    As a parent, I would have loved to shake her hand and thank her for calling attention to this. As an FYI, one of the abused deaf boys from Wisconsin sued the Catholic Church but it went nowhere. To be frank, he had a case. Thank you Sinead O’Connor, may you RIP.

    Keith

    Liked by 2 people

    • Thank you, Keith, I’m pleased you liked that one. I think hers is the best version I’ve heard.

      The scandal of the Catholic Church is widespread. I hadn’t heard of those over there but there have been many instances here and in Ireland which have got a lot of coverage. It’s a shame that her courage in calling it out was such a cause of vilification for her. I’ve always admired her. A troubled soul, and hopefully she is at peace now.

      Like

      • Clive, the movie “Spotlight” is excellent. It has a great cast. Boston is a very Catholic city, so taking on the Catholic Church was an uphill battle.

        Keith

        Liked by 1 person

      • Thanks for the tip. I’ve found it in two of my streaming services and have added it to my watchlists. At current rates I should get to it around 2028!

        Like

  5. On this my first visit to your blog, Clive (having not found the time to get here sooner), I wanted to do something positive, but as you may read on Jill’s reblog I had difficulties. However, it was on Jill’s reblog I found a reference to the following video that provided me what I hope is an acceptable offering in honour of Ms O’Coonor:

    Liked by 5 people

    • I haven’t seen your comments there but I’ll take a look. Thank you for dropping in here and sharing that one. I’d not seen it before, but it is unmistakably her beautiful voice.

      Liked by 2 people

  6. wow such a pretty girl even with no hair. I have to admire her standing up even in the compromise of her career. Thanks for sharing Clive. Talented and great musician. Sad to be gone so soon.. do we know what happened Clive? ❤️

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you, Cindy. She was lovely, and I always admired her for taking her stand. The police have said they found no suspicious circumstances but there will be a post mortem and possibly an inquest, so we may not know for a while yet.

      Liked by 1 person

      • I guess she stopped being box office there after her 1992 appearance on Saturday Night Live! I’ll try to remember to post an update, but it could be several weeks – or months – before the full story is known.

        Like

  7. Pingback: R.I.P. Sinead — Reblog | Filosofa's Word

  8. Thanks for the songs, a special tribute. Sad about her death, and sad about all she endured throughout life. Losing a child to suicide would be excruciating! I can’t imagine. There are things that we will never understand.

    Liked by 1 person

    • I’m glad you appreciated the tribute. I think she deserves to be recognised for all that she achieved as well as what she went through. I had feared that she had taken the same route as Shane, her son, but the police have reported no suspicious circumstances, which must be a comfort to her family.

      Liked by 1 person

  9. What a lovely tribute, Clive! I am not very familiar with Ms. O’Connor or her music, though I knew of her, naturally. She definitely had a beautiful voice, and put so much of herself into her music. I also enjoyed watching the interview (with captioning, for her I found her accent a bit difficult). Thanks … again, a great tribute!

    Liked by 1 person

      • It was! I’m getting used to the British accents from watching Coronation Street with my daughter, but her accent was much stronger somehow. I was surprised to find that I enjoyed most of the songs you played here … I guess I just never gave her a chance before!

        Liked by 1 person

      • You only get one of the many British accents from watching Corrie – try something Geordie or Scottish! I should point out that Sinead was fiercely proud of being Irish, which adds a whole new dimension to the range of accents! I’m glad you liked her songs – I think she was a very special talent and was surprised that I’d never played her before yesterday, apart from her Christmas song.

        Liked by 1 person

      • I’m sure that’s true, and I’m also pretty sure I’d have an even more difficult time with Scottish or Geordie accents! Perhaps if I had better hearing …

        Yes, I definitely enjoyed them and am also surprised you have only ever played her Christmas song … that was probably my least favourite of the batch.

        Liked by 1 person

  10. Nice tribute Clive. Lovely song choices. I don’t know her music that well but I should explore it more. I always liked her version of ‘The Foggy Dew’ with The Chieftains on their brilliant album ‘The Long Black Veil’.

    Liked by 1 person

    • Thank you, Paul, I’m glad you liked the tribute and the songs. I decided not to go for any of her many collaborations, but that is a great song on a fabulous album, isn’t it!

      Liked by 1 person

  11. I have always loved her hit “Nothing compares to you”. I never get tired of listening to it. Also, it always reminds me of my granddad. I heard the song in the car about 7 hours and 15 days after he passed away.

    Liked by 1 person

  12. I was never a fan of her music, but she was always interesting to listen to when it came to interviews. I had never seen this one. In reading about her life in the last day, I felt nothing but empathy for what she must have gone through when losing her child.

    Liked by 2 people

    • She was a troubled soul, and somehow made some very good music. Her 17yo son committed suicide, and though the family hasn’t yet said what the cause of Sinead’s death was I have a horrible feeling about it.

      Liked by 1 person

  13. An Irish warrior has passed! Demons chased her all her life but never overwhelmed her. She left a legacy of beauty. She never quit we shouldn’t either.

    Liked by 1 person

  14. Pingback: RIP Sinead O’Connor….A Tribute To The Music Of A Troubled Artist… – johnrieber

  15. Wow, didn’t even know this. I had to make my peace with her music over time, but appreciate her as a revolutionary and a guttural, emotional singer. “Put Your Hands On Me” may be bubblegummy for her, but I do love that song. I still talk about how Prince took the rights to “Nothing Compares 2 U” back from her after they’d had a fight and then he recorded the song as he’d written it. Playing both versions together, they each brought a raw emotion to it. RIP, Sinnead.

    Liked by 3 people

Please leave a reply, I'd like to know what you think

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.